P0420 Catalyst Efficiency Below Normal (Bank One)

This applies to vehicles equipped with OBD2 only. It basically means that your computer has detected that the Catalytic converter has failed on bank one. (Bank one is the side that the number one cylinder is on. Bank two is the other side.)  After the computer sees that this test fails so many time, will store this P0420 code in the computer and light the check engine light or MIL light.

Diagnosing P0420 catalyst efficiency code.

To be able to diagnose this p0420 converter efficiency code, we need to have a good understanding of how this system works. From all of my years going to class the easiest way I can describe it to you is that the catalytic converter stores oxygen. When it goes bad, it no longer has the ability to store oxygen and the computer will flag this P0420 code. On a computer controlled OBD2 vehicle, there will be one oxygen sensor before the cat and one after the cat. When the engine is running and is fully warmed up, the computer compares the two o2 oxygen sensor signals for a predetermined amount of time. If the converter is storing oxygen, then the rear oxygen sensor signal will produce a much different signal back to the computer than the front oxygen sensor. This is good. This is what the computer is looking for. This means the catalytic converter is doing its job (storing oxygen). When the computer sees that the two oxygen sensor signals are the same, this indicates that the catalytic converter is no longer storing oxygen like it should. The computer will then light your check engine light or malfunction indicator lamp and store the fault code P0420.

How do I know if my converter is bad?

If you get this P0420 diagnostic trouble code and you want to do some of your own testing, there are a number of ways to check the catalytic converter. One good way to check your converter to see if it is “lighting off”. This means that the converter is burning up the emissions on the inside. Remember, the hotter the converter gets, the cleaner it will run. The converter should be about 100 degrees hotter going out that coming in. You can use an infrared temp gun to do this test.  Here is an inexpensive one that can reach tempatures of 1000 degrees F.  To do this, you are going to want to be sure that the engine is full warmed up and then run the engine at 2000 rpm for about 1 to 2 minutes to prior to running this test.

Another thing that can happen is the converter can plug up and cause a false P0420 code in the computer. This usually happens when the engine has had a misfiring or rough running in the past and the customer continues to drive the vehicle for a long period of time. The converter will in fact get so hot that to the point that it will actually melt the brick inside into a ball. When it cools back down, it can tend to cause a low power issue and will eventually flag a P0420 code. You can use an exhaust back pressure tester to check for this condition.  Waekon makes a good exhaust back pressure tester.  I personally have this tool and would highly recommend it.

Here is a VeePeak code reader I recently picked up for cheap.   Upon reading codes stored in the computer, you can see there is a P0420 Diagnostic trouble code stored in the computer.   The definition for this code is Catalyst efficiency below threshold bank 1.   Basically, this means the computer has detected the converter on bank 1 is not storing oxygen like it should.   The computer is able to determine this by monitoring the front and rear oxygen sensors and comparing the readings.  Basically, if the two oxygen sensor signals are the same, the converter is not working and will flag this P0420 catalyst code.  This is on a 2004 Hyundai Elantra.  This particular vehicle only has a 4 cylinder engine so it only has one bank.  The numbers right below it 01/01 means 1 code of 1.   Meaning there is only one code stored in the PCM or computer and it is currently being displayed.   If there were more codes, the second number would indicate the amount of Diagnostic trouble codes stored in the computer.

Converter code
Pulling code from computer using scanner indicates P0420

False P0420

Why would the computer flag this code if the converter is good? What other possible causes would there be that would cause this p0420 code in the computer? Besides the two possible causes I mentioned above, there are several things to take into consideration. Exhaust leaks, bad oxygen sensor or sensors, lack of power to the oxygen sensor, bad PCM (computer) or even a PCM that needs to be updated or re flashed can all cause your P0420 catalytic efficiency code. If you have a P0420 code in the computer along with an oxygen sensor code, be sure to diagnose and fix the oxygen sensor code first before going after the p0420 code.


Plugged converters

Below are pictures of real plugged converters.   The first one is restricted beyond belief.  Air could simply NOT flow through the engine.   Not only the engine could not breath and did not accelerate, but the OBD2 on board the computer did flag the P0420 catalytic converter efficiency code.    The Brick inside the catalytic converter broke up restricting the exhaust system and causing this P0420 catalytic converter code.   However, upon taking this one apart, the debris came falling out once we got the converter removed from the vehicle.

Plugged converter
Broken chunks from inside the catalytic converter

Here is an interesting site that talks about this same P0420 diagnostic trouble code.  Below is a video explaining a bit about the catalytic converter and how it works.

One thought on “P0420 Catalyst Efficiency Below Normal (Bank One)

Comments are closed.